Cut Up the Box: The Hacker Who Cracked the Xbox
TL;DRAndrew 'Bunny' Huang cracked the Xbox's encryption in 2001 by intercepting its CPU bus, exposing the master key. MIT lawyers estimated his liability at $1 billion under the DMCA, leaving him to face the legal fallout alone.
In 2002, Andrew “bunnie” Huang told his MIT research group that he had, over the weekend, cracked the Xbox. His advisor told him to cut up the box on the bandsaw and never talk about it again. A law passed just four years earlier had made doing that illegal. Lawyers said the liability could reach a billion dollars. Then MIT told him he was on his own.
Since then he’s designed a surveillance detector for phones with Edward Snowden, written a book I enjoyed, built all sorts of open source technology, got in a lawsuit with the US government over that same law, and designed his own computer chip, which 27,000 hackers wore at DEF CON this summer.
It was late at night in his lab in Singapore and the sun was rising here when we sat down for a chat. We talked about patent culture in China, the big bet AI companies made when it comes to copyright law, and mostly, hacking video games. With AI now able to reverse engineer just about anything, it’s an interesting moment in that world, and he’s a fascinating figure in it.
Transcript
Machine-generated transcript; may contain errors.
Speaker 1: Closes the door, and he says, have you told anyone anything about this? And I was like, well, you know, I might have had some… I was like, if you haven't told anyone about this, I suggest you go upstairs to the band saw and just cut up the box, and we will never talk about this again.
Speaker 2: That was Andrew Bunny Huang's PhD adviser at MIT in 2002, after Bunny announced their group meeting that he had over the weekend, cracked the Xbox.
Speaker 3: That would be modding for the for the normies here.
Speaker 2: Back then, cracking the Xbox had very big implications because of a law that had passed just four years earlier that made doing that some shade of illegal.
Speaker 3: Some dark shade of illegal.
Speaker 2: Well, according to the lawyers who said that the liability for what he had done could reach about $1,000,000,000.
Speaker 3: Yeah. Today, probably more like 20,000,000,000.
Speaker 2: At which point MIT told him, Andrew, you are on your own.
Speaker 3: Godspeed, Andrew. Godspeed.
Speaker 2: Twenty four years later, it was late at night in Singapore in his lab, which is very, very cool. The sun was rising here, and the two of us sat down for a chat. Since all of that stuff with the Xbox went down, he's done fascinating work. He designed a surveillance detector for phones with Edward Snowden. He wrote a book that I really enjoyed, built all sorts of open source technology, got into a whole lawsuit with the US government over that same work, designed his own computer chip, which, at Defcon, I think this past year, had, like, almost 30,000 hackers rolling around, like, playing with this chip he designed. He's a fascinating guy. I wanted to talk about all of it. Andrew leaves it up to the person introducing him to choose how to introduce him, so I'm just gonna introduce him as a hacker. In the MIT roof and tunnel sense of the term, which I learned what this was, is someone who sees a locked door and needs to know what's behind it, not because they wanna steal anything, but because they just wanna know how the building works.
Speaker 3: Yeah. Curiosity. They wanna play the game.
Speaker 2: We talked about patent culture in China, the big bet that AI companies are making when it comes to copyright law, and most of the time was spent talking about hacking video games. It's a really fun conversation. This episode is brought to you by our title sponsor, NordLayer Intelligence by Nord Stellar. They're the threat exposure management platform that helps secure teams spot threats early, act faster. We're gonna tell you more about them later on. I really like this one. I think you're gonna dig it, Scott, with everything going on with, like, reverse engineering and AI.
Speaker 1: Totally. It's a
Speaker 2: really fascinating moment in the history of hacking games, and he's a fascinating figure in the history of hacking games.
Speaker 3: Yeah. Well, let's get into it.
Speaker 2: Let's do it. Andrew Bunny Huang, hacker, here on Hacked. You think of yourself first and foremost as, like, a hacker maker? Like, in your head, how do you think of the work you do?
Speaker 1: Yeah. I mean, I think I think I've always sort of… Personally, I've applied the term hacker to myself, but it doesn't mean what most people think… Like, most people think hacker is, like, the person who, like, breaks into stuff or whatever it is. I think of myself as more, like, a person who… I'm not constrained by the normal rules of what means to make stuff or to do things. Like, every… Everything's a system that, like, you know, like, I work alone. Whatever it is, but I have, like, this kind of weird… People try to describe what does I do. And it's like, I'm basically doing hacks on the corporate system and how, like Right. Silicon works and how business works. Like like, everything's open game for me to sort of, like, do, and it's not always, like, just trying to do security stuff, but, like, yeah, that kind of, like, attitude. It's like the original… The OG hacker ethos, like, the roof and tunnel hacker sort of thing, from MIT. That that… That's kind of where I I kind of pull that from, which is… It's hard. It's a long introduction to use because the word hacker just doesn't… It's not… I'm not like a sick… Like, exclusively security breaking into firewalls and stuff. It… Like, I build I build stuff too, but I'll build stuff in a way that's, like, unconventional.
Speaker 2: I'm super interested in that ambiguity between hacking things together and hacking them apart. That word is so designated towards hacking into things and hacking them apart. But you hear Right. People who make things and they describe it like, oh, we hacked this together. And I'm like, it's fascinating that that verb pulls dub… Double duty.
Speaker 1: It does. It… I mean, it… Yeah. I mean, we can get into it. I have I have a whole spiel about… You know, I had a… Back in my day, it wasn't the worst. Didn't it? But, you know, the… When the when the movie Hackers came out or wherever it is and then sneakers and, like, basically sort of cemented the the hoodie wearing console glowing view of a hacker. And there hasn't been, like
Speaker 2: Yeah.
Speaker 1: Exact… Yeah. Exactly.
Speaker 2: You sure. And, you
Speaker 1: know, and so and so then, like, Make Magazine came along and tried to coin the Eminem Make. Right? But but it… But that that isn't quite right because because because make… The make denim has a bit of a goody two shoes sort of Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 2: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 1: Feel to it. Right? You know? Like, a very family friendly appeal and, like, I I don't I don't… Like, like, a bit, a bit of my my shtick is breaking the rules and getting things done if they need to be. Like, you know, do do and ask for permission later kind of thing, which is not which is not kind of, like, you know, the the ethos of that system.
Speaker 2: You said something earlier that I wanna go back to, which I think a lot of people might not know anymore. You said the roof and tunnel definition of hacking.
Speaker 1: Yeah.
Speaker 2: Could you… Just for anyone who's unfamiliar, what is that?
Speaker 1: Right. This this comes from, like, if you went back to the Stephen Levy book about old hackers originally, and then also way, way, way back into sort of, like… So I I went to MIT, and they have this group of people called the roof and tunnel hackers. And, these are people who would just explore the roofs… Literally, the roofs and tunnels of the buildings themselves. So there'll be, like, a door that's locked, and you'd be like, Like, only the physical plant goes in there. I wonder where it goes. You'll learn how to pick the lock, and you'd go inside. And you'd be like, oh, wow. Like, the building is not just the facade. There's all these pipes on the inside. There's, like, secret passages on the inside. You can get on the roof and see down. Right. All sort of stuff in there. You would find secret passages between different buildings. And so in… Inside the institute, there became this sort of, like, thing that you would do, to sort of explore the buildings. And there was… There would be kind of neat because on the inside, you could tag your name in different different places. And so you would go into, like, these buildings. Like, how did someone tag their name on the very top of that? Like, you know, that that sort of… So there's a a bit of, like, exploration, kind of pushing the boundaries, learning new things aspect of the hacking. And so that's kind of that's kind of the knit… Kind of where I kind of picked up that that term from.
Speaker 2: That's so interesting. I think that's such a common thing that we we do, like, a call in show where people call in with their, like, computer tails and stuff and early hacks in their lives. And it's, like, that way of learning that on the far side of like a little boundary I'm not supposed to cross is the understanding of the whole system. That's such a common thing. It's fascinating to hear that it was formalized into an… Not formalized, but that it became its own kind of thing because of literally physical exploration.
Speaker 1: Yeah. Yeah. I mean, it's… It started as, like, you you could say, like, I was, like, hacking on the model railroad, or I was, you know, hacking on this problem set. Or, like, you know, it's just a term for, like, you're really into a thing, and and you're just gonna go at it. That's kind of what it more generically meant. And then it became very specific to computers and security after, like, the, you know, the movies and whatnot came out, you know, about hacking instead of that sort of stuff. So
Speaker 2: Yeah. Sure. It's fascinating how those terms get sort of, I don't know, calcified over time and narrowed.
Speaker 1: Yeah. I mean, English is a dynamic language. I mean, things have changed even over the past, like, couple decades. It's crazy. Yeah.
Speaker 2: Yeah. Feels like it's… That definition might be changing again now. I'm curious just really, really broadly. I I make indie video games. I love video games. That was how I learned about you was through your work with the Xbox at a super high level. Like, yeah. Why hack video games? Like, what is it about a video game that's a system that you're like, I wanna get on the roof of that, and I wanna get into the tunnels?
Speaker 1: Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah. I mean… So, I mean, really, it just starts with… You start playing the game, and at some point when the game… The game… The mechanic itself is broken. Like, I used to play, like, those little text games or wherever it is on, like, the IBM PC and that sort of thing. And then you'd be, like, going through the dungeons and being like, okay. Well, clearly, there's a bug in the game. And then you get out the debugger, and you just fix the bug in the game so you can keep playing the game. Well, if you're just gonna fix the bug, we're playing the game. Well, oh, look. I look at the variables in the stack. I'm like, oh, hey. Look. That looks like the amount of gold I have. I'm gonna increase that quite a bit. And you're like, okay. Now the game's a lot more interest. Oh, I'm gonna change the hit point to where… Like, you… And so, basically, it's sort of naturally evolved in sort of, like, a game plus plus sort of thing where… Like… And so from the very beginning, anytime I played a game and got bored of the game, I would get more value out of the game by essentially just messing around with the parameters a little bit and and seeing seeing what happens. So that would seem very natural to me.
Speaker 2: At what point did you switch to… I I know there's a lot of, like, time in between probably these anecdotes, but the the sort of 2,001, I think it was Xbox. I'll call it caper, but, like, the Xbox situation that I… Yeah. The reason I know… Situation. The reason I know what you is, I think you open… You you posted publicly a PDF of a book you wrote about this. I I guess just for anyone that doesn't know, like, can you just sort of tell me that story? Because I love that story. I've read that story. I would really Yeah. Appreciate hearing it from you.
Speaker 1: Yeah. Sure. Sure. No. I mean, so so, like, I mean… So I told you, like, I would just, like, walk around with the video games I played on my home computers, and then eventually, consoles came along. And then you'd be… Play the console game. The console game would suck at some point. You know, like, I wanna mess with the console. And then you would then, like, be like, oh, okay. Well, it's just a computer on the inside. What are consoles, but just computers? And so then you would start playing with… So, like, actually, even for the Xbox, like, the… I had a Nintendo. I had a Sega. I had all these… Like, the first thing I would do when I get the thing is I would, like, open up, find the ROM, dump it. Because at some point in time, I'm gonna, like, find a game that I'm not happy with anymore, and then I'm gonna wanna patch some values. And so that was just the thing I would do, as a matter of routine. And so the… I got the Xbox, and the first thing I did is dump the ROM. And then it turned out that thing was fully encrypted, and that was the first time we encountered anything like this. People were like, woah. Woah. Woah. This is interesting. And so then all of a sudden, the most interesting game, the Xbox, stopped being Halo. It started being… Figuring out how to decrypt the ROM. Right? Sure. So……
Speaker 2: Like, I'm playing this now. Yeah.
Speaker 1: Yeah. Well, I'm playing this now. I forget this this game over here. This game is way more interesting because I've never seen anything like it before. It's a new challenge. You know, there's a bunch of people who are looking at different approaches, and and, you know, I kind of just figured the software guys would figure it out eventually. There's a lot of people who are very talented at the the software reverse engineering. But it turns out the way that, Xbox security worked is they actually had, like, this deliberately, fake, like, booby trap decoy boot sector. So even though you you dumped everything out and you read it out, it wouldn't actually work because some fake values were put in to sort of throw people off. And people are like, woah. Woah. Woah. Like, how does this even work? We've never seen it like this. And so eventually turned up at the at the time, you know, my… I was doing my PhD work, and my thesis was on supercomputers. And if you're doing supercomputers, basically, you're doing fast wires. That's really kind of what it boils down to. What really slows down computers in day's pocket is is is wiring. And so I just happened to have an extremely fast network custom thing that I built for my thesis. It was very configurable and very powerful. And so I built this adapter board for that, which then I could then solder into my Xbox. And I could listen to the CPU as it booted as it talked to the rest of the hardware. And then across that bus was the master key that… The true master key that encrypted the actual contents of the ROM. And once that was out, then cats out of the bag. Everyone would… Could then do all this… All the software bits to it. Right? So that's, yeah, that's kinda basically how it came about at the end of the day.
Speaker 2: I would say that that is making the story of what, like, then happened seem much smaller than it is. It's like, okay. That's how you got in.
Speaker 1: After that part, after that was, like… Yeah. Yeah. After that, then there were there were, like,
Speaker 2: Some stuff.
Speaker 1: Yeah. There was, like, the… Yeah. The real… I mean, so the… So this is 2001, and the Yeah. It just so happened in 1998. A new law was passed that made this all incredibly illegal. So the the thing that I have to remind people is that I I was born in 1975, and the world I grew up in, this was legal. Right? It didn't become illegal until a certain time in college. Right? And so, of course, I was just going along doing things I did. And when I when I when I finally… I was… I went to my my adviser, you know, during the group meeting. I was like, hey. Guess what I did, you know, this this past weekend. Like, blah blah blah. He, like, closes his door, and he says, have you told anyone anything about this? And I was like, well, you know, I might have had some… He's like, if you haven't told anyone about this, I suggest you go upstairs to the band saw and just cut up the box, and we will never talk about this again. And you will not have to deal with anything. I was like, well, there might be… He was like, okay. We're gonna have to get some lawyers. We're gonna have to get you blah blah blah, whatever it is. And so, like… So then I told, like, lawyers by the dealers, like, well, this is a new law. We don't know what it means, but it carries, like, a 2,000, $202,500 dollar penalty per instance. And so you could be liable for a billion dollars for the damage because, like, every pirate of the game from Yeah. From Microsoft, they could claim is your fault because you're the ones who pulled the security out and blah blah blah. And so wrote this whole dossier, brought it to the MIT, sort of lawyers. And this is, like, the the… Really, to this day, I've never forgiven MIT for this. Like, they they called me into a meeting, and they they they took this sheet of mill… In mineral oil papers and handed back to me and says, so we understand that, this this month here, you're… We're not in semester. I'm like, yeah. Yeah. It's it's IAP. It's like the month between, you know, sort of winter and spring. It's like, well, that means you… The work you did was kind of independent of MIT. I was like, yeah. I was doing kind of a hobby thing on my home. I mean, I used your stuff, but it was like, well, in that case, we never opened this and looked at this. It's a signed seal thing. You have nothing to do with… You did this as an ink pen research. Good luck. You're on your own against Microsoft. Yeah. I was, like, so pissed about that. And they've they've had a history of doing this. I mean, Aaron Swartz got laid under the… You know? And then, you know, Star Simpson had no support from this. The institute just… It's such a self serving… Sorry. I mean, it really… They have a bad history of supporting students who have done what I think is actually makes that institute really interesting and great, which is, like, this sort of idea that you can, you know, explore and disobey and transgress and and you would still have, like, this… You know? And so what it turned out actually in the day was then, I got connected with people from the EFF who are much more sympathetic, you know, and and and and they gave me really good advice. I wrote an academic paper about it. It got submitted to CHES, which is this cryptographic hardware engineering embedded systems conference. They accepted the paper. And then Sure. Basically, after that point in time, Microsoft was like, oh, oh, well… And, also, the other thing is… This is also very nice. The director of the lab, I think it was Rodney Brooks at the time. I was at the AI, CS lab at MIT at the time. And, he was just like, the institute's wrong. I'm a let you publish this under an an AI lab techno. So, basically, you have this internal lab publication. So I published it under that. So he basically says, no. You actually are part of our tribe. But the instant one do it, they can they can they can talk to me about it, and a couple other presses stood for me. And then I got submitted… Accepted the paper in Chez. And then Microsoft basically responded to our conversation of, like, well, it would look really bad if we sued an act… A legitimate academic researcher who's working on his PhD and has done everything right in terms of disclosure and whatever it is. So, like, you know, just please, like, change these few things about your paper, and and we can go on about our weight. And so then, like, yeah, I live to fight another day. It was Wow. It was a lot for me to take in in my twenties. It was really a lot. Right.
Speaker 2: You were in your twenties during that. That is buck wild. There was, like, a line in your in in your book. You say, I fear that the era of civil disobedience may be coming to a close. I'm fascinated by, like, that doesn't to me sound like an era where civil disobedience was open. It… That sounds like the same thing that we have now where lawyers are gonna lawyer and they're all… Everyone's gonna protect the institutional power. Like, did you… Did it feel different then to now? Is that era you're talking about even earlier?
Speaker 1: Yeah. I mean, I think before… Even before… I mean, like, the whole civil disobedience era was actually even going back to Martin Luther King's time and all. Like, that was, like, really for the true sort of era in this… In in the fifties and sixties and the… And and women's suffrage, these sorts of things.
Speaker 4: Sure.
Speaker 1: And then it… And then over the seventies and eighties, it sort of started to get clawed back. Rights got clawed back more and more. And then, you know, now we enter into the nineties and two thousands. You sort of see that window close, and it just keeps closing and closing. Like, we get more and more, like, ever since, like, you know, the Patriot Act and and a bunch of these, you know, CFAA get passed and a whole bunch of other things that basically everybody wants to be safe, which is good good thing to want to do. But, also, you're sort… It sort of becomes, like, this catchall thing where, like, any sort of resistance, any sort of, like, protests, any sort of, difference of opinion from, like, the institutions Yeah.
Speaker 2: Sure.
Speaker 1: Can become criminalized. You can become a terrorist. You can be whatever it is. And so now it becomes very hazardous and risky to even try to think different at the end of the day. So it is making some part of society safer, but also it's subject to abuse from people who just want to control things and prevent civil disobedience. And I do… It's it's gotten hard and much harder and more risky, particularly recently in United States, to to do these kinds of civil disobedience. So I I do… I… You know, it is… It's a sort of thing where I… Where, you know, I'm young and I'm old enough to remember how it was back in the… How it felt, and it does feel materially different now. And it… And and it's one of those things I wish I could sort of… What I really want is I want to show people a world before the DMCA. It's, like, so cool when you could just, like, trade songs, mix tapes, you know, go to the library and just copy pages. I mean, there was there was copyright infringement. That's a thing. And that that… That's a legitimate issue. Right? Yeah. But then it wasn't, like, a literal crime also to break the lock on the encryption as well, which sort of added this other kind of, like, additional crime to the whole thing, which made it made it made a huge difference in terms of, like, how people thought about business, how businesses ran, the the risk appetite of different startups, for doing the… It… And, anyways, it's it's really changed.
Speaker 2: Yeah. Well, I'm I'm curious to keep talking about that if you're down because I I feel like that theme of, you know, a pre and post DMCA world. I I mean, you've done… You've been living in that intersection for a really long time, the work that you did. I know you you hacked together like a radio transmission scanner thing after Stone happened for a journalist Marie Colvin. Like, you have been… You've been kind of hanging out in that space of, like, in that really interesting space. So I'm curious just for anyone that doesn't know DMCA, like, what was that? What was before that? What is the era that we've been living in now? Because I think a lot of people don't even really know that we're in the after of that and kind of have been for decades.
Speaker 1: Oh, yeah. It's been so… And so, basically, what is the actual DMCA Yeah. Do? Yeah. Yeah. So, yeah, it's actually really interesting to to hear all the the details of it, and and it's… Their origins that are even more crazy than what we had known at the time. But, essentially, like, there's this thing called copyright, which says that if you're, like, an author of a book or a song, you have some certain amount of time exclusive right to it. It is a crime to copy someone's stuff and sell it as your own. Right? Not give them… That's that's been well established, like, forever. More recently, it became… If if a copy was protected by Mhmm. Anything, the flimsiest of locks, the shammiest of shams. Right? So you you… To get a book, and there's, like, a little tiny, like like, Tumblr code of three digits on the side. And you say, like, you know, you can't open this book unless I give you this code. If if you just open the book, you own the book, but you open that book without the authorization of that code, that is a crime now. Like, you can own… Here's the thing is you can own the book. You have bought the book, but if you do that without the permission of the copywriting, you break that thing. It is now a crime. So this is like… So this whole thing of, like, you know, you can buy a song, but now you can't listen to it anymore is a new thing that is actually a result of the DMCA, versus, like, before when you bought a song, you just bought a song. Like, it was, like, there was no other sort of thing that would prevent you from doing that. So this is one of those weird things that has happened, and and it was 1998 that this whole thing transitioned over, like, just as the Internet was getting big. And so, like, the Internet kind of grew up with a sort of weirdness about it. Although, you know, the… It's very interesting because I've also spent quite a bit of time in China as well. And that place essentially operated DMC free internally. They didn't they didn't… And so and so it's very interesting to sort of see how their ecosystem developed, what they did with, you know, how the rip mix burn culture works, how they share IP. And and and, you know, there's sort of, like, this general theory that you have to have the strong IP protection. Otherwise, why would anyone invest in creating a big business or something? Because you can't, like, reap the monopoly gains of of of your investment for, like, decades or whatever it is. Right? That… That's the theory. But Yeah. It's it's, you know, that that sort of competitiveness they have, as a result of sort of, like, the sort of sort of lesser… They would say lesser IP protect. There's still some IP protection, but not as strong as as it would be out here. Created a much more, I would say, like, diverse and robust manufacturing ecosystem. Part of the reason, like, the the manufacturing, is so efficient out in China. So there's there's a story I heard once. Like, you know, they're they're very strong in solar cell manufacturing. Right? Mhmm. And so when you make a solar cell, you have, like, a bowl of silicon. You have to cut it up with a wire and… Into the solar cells. And that wire… The width of that wire is lost silicon. The width of the wire used to be something like point one millimeters. And then one factory figured out how to make it, like, point o seven millimeters, so 30% thinner, which means you got, like, 10 or 15% more solar cells out of a single chunk of silicon. Right. And, normally, in a IP heavy ecosystem, it would take decades for that to work its way through the system because the person would have a patent on it. They would license it, and you would… You you would want to capture that 10 or 15% money and take that as your reward for having thought of how to make that wire thinner. Literally, within, like, a month and a half, two months, every factory in China was now offering 10 to 15% more efficiently in terms of cranking out solar cells. Because the moment one factory found, the next factory had to implement it. Otherwise, they would lose business. And that… Like, that's just how that ecosystem works. It's… You know, on the on the one hand, there's one guy who probably could have made billions of dollars, you know, if he could monetize that innovation of the thinner wire. On the other hand, you now have 10 to 15 more percent more solar cells coming out of an entire ecosystem overnight. And, you know, your, you know, all the other benefits, saving the environment, getting, you know, green energy out there, whatever it is, because because there's just this different sort of attitude around IP. It's it's really interesting case study.
Speaker 2: Yeah. I've read a bit of your writing about… And I'm gonna butcher the pronunciation here, so please correct me. Huaqiangbei?
Speaker 1: Huaqiangbei. Yeah.
Speaker 2: Huaqiangbei. It… Like, for anyone that doesn't know, it's this, like, sprawling electronics district in Shenzhen. And the reason I'd heard about it… I'm curious to go there. I know you've gone, I think, with MIT students.
Speaker 1: Mhmm. Yeah.
Speaker 2: Maybe a few times. If you were ever going again in the future, please let me know, because I have questions. Yeah.
Speaker 1: And I regularly just go for the fun of it. It's a it's a real… It's a nerd paradise. It's so much Dude, don't cool to check it out.
Speaker 2: Don't threaten me with a good time. I will I will take you up on this. But I was I was fascinated by… You'd kind of… I don't think you coined this term. You popularized it or at least introduced me to it as this idea of, like, again, Gong Kai?
Speaker 1: Yeah. Gong Kai. Yeah.
Speaker 2: Yeah. Gong Kai.
Speaker 1: That's the term I coined. It's not an actual Chinese word. I I coined it.
Speaker 2: But You coined that term. K. I I… That's what I thought, and I got speed wobbles on saying coined in case you had just popularized it.
Speaker 1: Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 2: Yeah. But it's just, like, it's a super interesting thing if you have this semi kind of open ish culture of, like, shared references and designs, people remixing stuff. It's very pre DMCA with digital stuff, but about hardware and physical site. Yeah. Yeah. And the tension between that and the Western patent culture. Yeah. I guess, like, you've talked about it a little bit, but I'm really curious just to hear you talk about, like, well, what are the pros and cons of each? You make $12,000,000,000 if you figure out how to make a a filament or, like, a wire thinner is a pro to the other speed. Like, just talk a little bit more about that.
Speaker 1: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So so the reason why I thought I even had to coin a new word was that there is actually a word for open source in Chinese, but it refers specifically to open source in the Western legal sense, where you have a license Oh. Like a Creative Commons or a GPL or whatever it is. And the thing I'm trying to describe is that it's it's… The source is out there de facto. It's publicly open. Right. But but there isn't a strong legal basis, but in practice, everyone just shares it. Right? And it's and it's… The reason why this works in the ecosystem and people don't just completely, you know, stab each other in the back is they have this other alternate system called Guangxi. It's like this the… They call the face, sort of like this reputational system. And so, you know, in practice, what would happen is maybe the guy who's sharing, like, the wire trick would have gotten big Guangxi from having shared it with other factories. So later when another factory comes with its innovation, he's first in line to get their improvement, and his factory will get more business. So it's just kind of like this mutual, I'll give this idea to you if you give your idea to me, and it really works on kind of a trust basis. You know, like, a really sort of face to face. It's a it's a very different system. But, overall, I would say the pros and cons is that, like, the Western system is very good at sort of giving credit to what I call named inventor. Right? So this is kind of this Tony Stark kind of idea. We have, like, this singular genius that I… Like, one of my favorite pictures is, like, this Renaissance artist had shown a picture of an alchemist discovering phosphorus. And this is old white guy sort of kneel… Knelt down in front of this glowing white flask, and he keeps, like, discovering phosphorus. In the back are a couple other, like, you know, lab assistants who who… Whatever. They don't need… They don't deserve the attribution for the trappers anyway. But, really, this is the name genius, right, at the end of the day. And and, but the but the idea is that it does reward incredibly high risk, investment. So, for example, a place where this may work well is, like, drug discovery. You you have to spend twenty years, lots of investment, billions of dollars. You don't want to have the chemical formula come out and then immediately have it go away, and you don't recover the billions of dollars. Right? This is… So there are areas where this is a better match. Twenty years, whatever, patent like, this kind of thing. Then you go to the Internet. Twenty years patent like, like, how old is the Internet? Right? Like, it's, like, insane. And then copyright, for example, like, memes are this really weird place where, like, there's this point in time where people are like, well, I had to sign a waiver once, like, you know, all images here, I have permissions to use. And I had a couple memes in there. I'm like, well, who is the copyright holder of this picture of this cap? Like, I can't even find that person, right, at the end of the day. How do I even, like, and and so what it is is that, like, the the… In in in service modern Internet IP ecosystem, it's more about virality that's important. Ideas only survive if they are… If there's no friction for them being adopted. And what what people are looking for is the idea to be out. They want it to be viral. And in a way, like, the the creators maybe sort of take from this, like, yeah. I took that cat picture, and I see it everywhere. Right? You know, maybe they don't get a lot of attribution for it. But but internally, they're like, yeah. I I kind of push, you know, they've they've moved the things forward or whatever. But you don't get monopoly benefits, but there's some sort of personal benefit, for for these smaller sorts of things. And so… But, you know, it's a cat picture at the end of the day. Like, you know, are you gonna sue every publisher in the world, every website in the world for having this picture of this this cat and extract dollars from it. Like like, you know, it's it's… When you get… When you read it down to the level of, like, a cat picture has to be, you know, now heard out with lawyers and and, you know, it really, slows down the the spread of ideas. Right?
Speaker 2: Yeah.
Speaker 1: And so and so with Internet age, and Moore's law and the speed of technology, it turns out this this sort of sort of Gong Kai approach actually tended to be a bit of a stronger, so… No. That's right. I would say a better match in terms of speed and pace, retirement of ideas, spread of ideas, to that ecosystem.
Speaker 2: It doesn't incentivize the initial upfront investment, but it does incentivize the speed and creativity that Remix culture also kind of incentivizes.
Speaker 1: Right. Right. And so in that in that ecosystem, what you find is it tends to be that if you are a means of production or a producer, a person who loves to produce, it rewards you. So if you're a very prolific blogger or social media person, you're just throwing that stuff out there. You're not caring about who's paying you for it, but, like, you get the eyeballs, then that that rewards that sort of… Or if you're a factory, for example, and you're just building phones of different types and people are maybe borrowing your phone ideas wherever it is, but then they want they want a version of that. They… They'll come to your factories. You're the number one maker of that phone. And so, yes, a few other people are are knocking you off, but you are also growing your business. You're raising the tide for all shifts. And you and you you tend to find it to be a generally a better match if you have means of production or means of creation under your control. Whereas if you don't have that and you're outsourcing all of it or Yeah. You're not able to do this sort of stuff, and you really want to be much more sort of restrictive and pull all that IP back so you can monetize it.
Speaker 2: It feels like the rubber meeting the road. Like, there there is to go back to that that painting of the one the one dude discovering alchemy. The alchemist, and then there's, like, the seven people that, like Yeah. We're also alchemists. They were like, yeah.
Speaker 1: Yeah. Exactly. Yeah.
Speaker 2: Yeah. It's, it feels that it's… There's a tension there, right, of, like, the the Western Catapan. I made this. I own this. I invested in it. If 20 other people helped me, it was because I paid them. Therefore, it is sort of mine. It's like That's right. Yeah. It becomes… It sort of reveals itself as, like, oh, that really is a very long in the tooth way of understanding, not just the legal side of things, but what does it mean to create things? It's like creativity is nine times out of 10 deeply collaborative. There's like a… There's a tension there.
Speaker 1: Total crazy thing is like… So I hold several patents, like, whole Yeah. They would pull.
Speaker 2: Sure.
Speaker 1: I actually own none of them because they were all applied for in the context of a company. And when I joined the company, I signed all of my rights to mention over. I leave the company, and I can no longer use the things I invented. I don't own them. So so, like, there's this crazy thing where, like like, I built this thing called the NETV, which is, like, the sort of man in the middle attack against HCCP, whatever it is. And, I left Chumby at the time and wanted to sort of sell this technology, but the IP, the patent on it was lodged with Chumby, the company I was with before, which then got licensed out to Best Buy. And so this ridiculous conversation I'm having, trying to do an open source project, trying to negotiate with someone from best… Best Buy on a license to a thing I invented. I'm just like…
Speaker 2: Unreal.
Speaker 1: Oh my god. I'm never filing for patent ever again unless it's, like, in… Literally in my own name. Right? And and this is part of the reason why I'm super duper onto the open source side is because, like, after having been to the cycle of of… Been through companies and I had to… Like, every time leave a company, I'm, like, zero. Starting from zero every single time. All the IPs assigned over the company, and you're just walking up the door with a box with a coffee bug in it and, like, a… And, like, some pictures of yourself… Your own. That's it. I have nothing to show for what I… If I do
Speaker 2: it in
Speaker 1: the open source domain, when I leave the company or I move on, I still have that effort I did. I'm actually just building on layer after layer after layer. My career had actually really didn't take off until I really started getting into open source because… And part of it is, like, I just really wanted to be able to… I really believe in the things I built, and I want to use the things I built, and I want to make them better over time. I don't even want to have them be dependent on a corporation. It can be permission to improve the things I've built. Right?
Speaker 2: This episode is brought to you by our title sponsor, NordLayer Intelligence by Nordsteller.
Speaker 3: Here's something that comes up in almost every story we cover. The attack rarely starts with a break in. It starts earlier, a leaked password, a session cookie stolen by an Infos dealer malware, or someone on the dark web forum selling access to your network.
Speaker 2: NordLayer Intelligence watches that whole world for you. Monitors more than 40,000 deep and dark web sources for your company's leaked credentials, active session cookies, and mentions of your brand, executives, partners, all that stuff. It alerts you in real time so your team can act early.
Speaker 3: It also maps your external attack services and catches impersonation attempts all from one dashboard. Most companies take months to realize that they've been breached. With NordLayer Intelligence by Nord Stellar, you can see your actual leaked data in your very first demo.
Speaker 2: Book one at nordlair.com/intelligence/hackedpodcast and mention the code hacked podcast 10 for 10% off.
Speaker 3: That's nordlair.com/intelligence/hackedpodcast.
Speaker 2: I feel like we're seeing this a lot in the video game industry right now where you have these these teams who created a bunch of intellectual property. The owner of that team sold it up the line to a bigger company, who now owns all of that intellectual property, years pass and they decide, let's stop paying for this to keep happening, the team no longer has work, and they don't own the intellectual property that they had created. And now that intellectual property
Speaker 1: behind it.
Speaker 2: Blood, sweat, and tears. And it's just, like, gone into the void. And it's, like Yeah.
Speaker 1: Tear my heart out. It it sucks.
Speaker 2: It's like a… It's like the shell game where you have a thing under the three cups, but somehow the thing is gone. I'm like, wait. There was there was a nut under one of those cups. Where did it go?
Speaker 1: Yeah. Yeah. It's mad. It's it's it's so crushing for for creators. And then also, there's this, like, crazy thing where, like, I can never own my childhood. The things I love as a child are still in copyright. Right? So I can't remix any of those things. I owe… Like like, it just seems like the the copyright duration is so incredibly long compared to, like, what I would like to do with it. And so, you know, I could perform, I wouldn't say get rid of it. I would say shorten that or make different categories. I'm sure it's never gonna happen. But, like, you know, it's… It is one of those things where that story of the creator is just not being able to… Like, they put blood, sweat, and tears to create characters they love, create create scenarios that have their fans that love them, people who want more of it. And just out of a corporate decision, it's not profitable anymore. It's not the the most profitable thing we could do. Therefore, no one can have it. We're just gonna keep it up. It it Yeah. This story happens all the time, and it's because of this, yeah, this this incredible system that we have.
Speaker 2: This just happens to a company that I I I played their games for a long time, BioWare. And it's… That's a comp… That's a complex sit… Situation Yeah. That I I don't know. But but it does occur to me that, the moment of the company getting killed was preceded by a long time of the company having to do what the owner said. So there's something about, like, oh, the games weren't working. The IP wasn't selling. The last couple titles weren't a hit. And it's like, but you were telling them what to do during that window of time. Like Yeah. Yeah. Do do we not see attention here, friends?
Speaker 1: Yeah. Yeah. Exactly. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. This is… Yeah. It's brutal. So It's it's brutal. It's
Speaker 2: k. I wanna go back to to copyright a little bit. I didn't know a lot about copyright. Nilay Patel at The Verge, who has a sort of a legal background, talks a lot about it, and he was where I sort of understood that it's literally just at a very base level, those laws are just saying, what happens when you make a copy? Like, just a copy of something that's why it's it's copyright, which breaks down anytime you have a new technology. When you're sending a a piece of data from, like, the computer to the screen just to show it is technically copying it. So we had to relitigate that VHS as every time we get new tech,
Speaker 1: and
Speaker 2: that that's a feature not a bug that you want the law to be obtuse so you have to relitigate it every single time there's new technology and it seems like sometimes that litigation falls really… It's like a pendulum that swings. Sometimes it's really favoring the copyright holder and sometimes it's really favoring remix culture.
Speaker 1: Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 2: And I'm curious, like, the moment that we're living right now where we have all of this software, generative AI and agentic AI that's fundamentally based on a massive copying process. That is that… That is now suddenly very, very allowed. We're suddenly really, really okay with that copy and paste in place. I'm curious for your thoughts about that.
Speaker 1: Allowed. Yeah. I mean, again, like you said, it has to be relitigated. So I think I think what the truth is that Yeah. There are people with long memories about how these things happen. And and if they have a lot of money, what they do is they they know that it has to be relegated. They know how long it takes. And so so the allow… The allowed sort of air quotes around, you know, kind of AI taking everyone's work and incorporating into this model, which can then generate derivative works, ad nauseam. I think they know exactly what they're doing. It's kind of just, you know, asking, you know, ask for permission later. Right? Just do it and ask for… Like, just break the rules and and go forward. Not… Break the rules would… They would object with that.
Speaker 2: Yeah. Totally….
Speaker 1: Say, like, these rules are ambiguous. We can litigate after we have done… And and I think their bet is that it's gonna be so useful, so pervasive, where they have so much money that at the end of the day, they'll either be able to buy everyone out Mhmm. Or buy the buy the lawyers, buy the judges, buy the system, or people will just not be able to do without it. So the system just has to make this retroactively legal somehow. Because, like, if you just say, we're gonna just go throw out all the AI or we're going to, like, whatever is, like, it just, like, of all things would break at that point in time. So, like, okay. We we we broke the jar. Now now let's talk about whether I should have broken it or not. Right? That's kind of Yeah. Yeah. They it's a it's a very… I think they knew exactly what they're doing in these cases. And the the kind of the… Of course, it it does seem like it's switching… Swinging more to the sides of, like, oh, yeah. Copying is is okay because they're doing this. But I have a feeling it's gonna end up based, like, rules for me, but not for these sort of thing situation where Yeah. These guys are going to be putting pressure on to make sure that other people… Maybe in the future, they'll make it illegal. Like, oh, sorry. Sorry. Sorry. No one should break jars in the future. Like, let's just grandfather these in, and and and we'll just make our jars the only jars that are broken. Great. Like, you know, that would also be a a completely fine sort of, like, status quo for… There's a whole lot of ways to cut this at the end of the day. And this is, again, where the legal system is, like, a kind of a poor match for technology because it really will take decades to hear this out. And I mean, we're… It's 2026. DMCA is 1998. We're still hearing case, but there's still ambiguities. I cannot answer. There's so many things you can't answer about the DMCA today. Like, we've been trying for ages to get clarity on, like, even, like, the NEPB case, for example. It just… It just ended ambiguous. I even… We tried to suing the US government to get a ruling on it, and it it was basically like, like, you know, who know… Who knows? Like, we're gonna throw on some technicality and not rule on any of it. Okay. Okay. That's rather unsatisfying for, like, a decade of effort to try and get an answer on something. Right? So so there's… There is, like, this you know, it's kind of like, if you know that that the, you know, the the the arm of the law can swing and hit you at a bat, but only swings at a rate of, like, a millimeter a year. Right? And you are moving around at the speed of light. You can just, you know, do what you want and just… You just watch that thing come down. And then finally, wherever it lands, you just step out of the way and you, like, walk around it. And it's… You know? That that that… That's kind of how it feels right now. Like, there… You know? And I'm glad that the legal system is… Well, used to be thorough and fair. Right? But, you know, it it is a lot of… It's a it's a tough time to be in to watch this whole thing sort of Yeah. Fall apart in a way. You know?
Speaker 2: Sure.
Speaker 1: A lot
Speaker 3: of people don't know, but, like, a ton of retail sales occurred during the holiday season. Like, that should be… Should make sense to everybody. So if you're thinking about starting an online ecommerce store, now is the time. You wanna be in market before Black Friday, before Christmas. You wanna be in market when people are spending money.
Speaker 2: Shopify gives people the tools they need to launch, sell, and grow during this busy busy season. Shopify helps you launch a store and start selling in a few simple steps without needing to be an ecommerce expert. Sidekick, Shopify's AI assistant, can help with business tasks along the way from store setup to planning promotions.
Speaker 3: We use Shopify for our hackmer store, which you might have seen. And if you haven't, you should check it out. And Shopify is great. Integrates with everything, integrates with the the fulfillment providers. Integrates with everything. The themes are great. Everything's great. Takes care of everything. Everything is good. Everything. Everything. Everything. Everything. Everything. Everything.
Speaker 2: Launch before Black Friday. A time of year when most people are already shopping and ready to buy. Launch before Black Friday means you can take advantage of extra online traffic. If you're ready to launch your business before Black Friday, go to shopify.com/hacked. Start your free trial.
Speaker 3: Go to shopify.com/hacked today to hear your first
Speaker 2: You know what your cloud bill is. You know what your headcount costs. Now go ahead and try this one on. What did your company spend on AI tokens last month, and what exactly did you get out of it? Most businesses can't really answer that even though it's the fastest growing category in business spend.
Speaker 3: Ramp is a financial operations platform used by more than 70,000 businesses to manage and control spending. Now Ramp is bringing the same visibility and control to AI. With Ramp, you can see spending across AI providers, set real time controls and guardrails by team, by model, and understand what spend is actually moving the needle for your business. And unlike other providers, Ramp isn't incentivized to get you to spend more on AI. Ramp is the only company that works with you to ensure your AI spend is going to the highest ROI areas. If your business is spending on AI, you should be using token spend management by Ramp.
Speaker 2: We've used Ramp before. You should too. Stop guessing where your AI spend is going and get started with Ramp. And if you're new to Ramp, you can get $250 off at ramp.com/hacked. Go to ramp.com/hacked. That's ramp.com/hacked.
Speaker 3: Your phone and laptop don't stop connecting just because you stop using them. They can still share your location and sync data in the background. Those connections can help big tech and governments track you and give hackers a way in.
Speaker 2: That's why we started using Silent. They make Faraday bags that physically block wireless signals to and from your device you put inside. You you you close the bag and the connection… What does it do? It stops.
Speaker 3: No app. No settings. No subscription. And it's just a bag that I carry. It's a simple way to take some control back over your privacy. Check them out at silent.com/hacked. That's slnt,novowels,.com/hacked.
Speaker 2: Use hacked to check out to get yourself 15% off and free shipping on qualifying orders. This episode is brought to you by our title sponsor, NordLayer Intelligence by Nordsteller.
Speaker 3: Here's something that comes up in almost every story we cover. The attack rarely starts with a break in. It starts earlier, a leaked password, a session cookie stolen by an Infos dealer malware, or someone on the dark web forum selling access to your network.
Speaker 2: NordLayer Intelligence watches that whole world for you. Monitors more than 40,000 deep and dark web sources for your company's leaked credentials, active session cookies, and mentions of your brand, executives, partners, all that stuff. It alerts you in real time so your team can act early.
Speaker 3: It also maps your external attack services and catches impersonation attempts all from one dashboard. Most companies take months to realize that they've been breached. With Nord Lair Intelligence by Nord Stellar, you can see your actual leaked data in your very first demo.
Speaker 2: Book one at nordlair.com/intelligence/hackedpodcast and mention the code hacked podcast 10 for 10% off.
Speaker 3: That's nordlair.com/intelligence/hackedpodcast.
Speaker 2: I think that, rules for thee but not for thee is, like, a really interesting way of talking about it. Because I think that we've all lived through this couple of years where we were all being told, oh, no. No. No. No. We… None of these laws apply to this technology. We can we can kind of do whatever we want. And just in the last couple weeks, we're starting to see that, like… But this same technology can be used… So the software companies are are telling us that this is allowed, but the same software is capable of reverse engineering your product software. Yeah. You see this anytime, you know, a a model that was trained on a bunch of copywritten data suddenly
Speaker 1: Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 2: Suspicion that someone is is learning from it. Exactly. Distillation.
Speaker 1: You stole from the thief. Oh my god. Like
Speaker 2: Exactly. I'm curious when do you think that the the snake kinda starts eating its own tail a little bit where Adobe's get so mad at Photoshop being, you know, recompiled or whatever that we… The pendulum, like, heaves back in the other direction. Or do you think that pendulum is like, no. Gravity no longer applies. It is just going off in a venture capital fuel direction. We can't stop it.
Speaker 1: It's it's really hard to say actually where anyone is going because, actually, the entire legal system doesn't really… It's changed a lot. Like, the composition of, like, just… Yeah. The rule… The ground rules have all changed in a way. It's it's very hard to… For me to to call back to past precedent and say, like, yeah. I really think this is going to apply because there's so many other but this, but this, but this, but this. At at the end of the day, it's it's one of those things where I I kind of feel like, you know, my my approach is, like, just use common sense and the best judgment that I have. Right. And just know that that no matter what I do, there's gonna be a party who's not gonna be happy with the outcome. Like, someone is gonna want to change the law one way or the other. But then as long as I do something that I generally think is, like, in the public's best interest, kind of squarely, like, not, like, being super greedy about it. You know? This is part of the reason I do the open source work, and I want to, like, do things in a way that that sort of you can see this public good side of it. That if it were to go to a litigation, I can be like, well, at least, you know, if if you make this wrong, then all these other things go along along with it. So it really becomes… Almost every three things sort of becomes this, in my mind, like a, like, yeah. I understand there's a lot of risk right now, but we're just gonna have to get used to the idea that risk is is material in a venture redo. You can get more comfortable with that. And a lot of it is more of just, like, now we're in deep water, but you know what? Like, we have each other. We have the public. We have our friends. And as long as we support each other, we'll get through this. Right? And and and that's kind of where I'm where I'm at right now on this stuff. Because otherwise, I'd be paralyzed. I couldn't… I wouldn't do anything. Right? Like, there's no… I don't… And I don't want to live that way. I want to continue to create and innovate and do things I care about. And so I have almost no choice but sort of, like, fall back to this sort of, like, just I'm gonna have faith that people are good in a way. And if I do the right things, like, may… You know?
Speaker 2: Yeah.
Speaker 1: We'll find out. You know? Just just try. Like, there's nothing I can do.
Speaker 2: Yeah. It's like a faith and solidarity that if we all have kind of the shared interest, that maybe that maybe can win out.
Speaker 1: Yeah. Read the room, and then, you know, just talk to people. Try to be… Don't be a dick. Be a good person. I mean, these are really simple rules, it sounds like. Right? But, you know, it's it's it's… These sound like really obvious things, but I… But but but you but you look at the… Where things are going sometimes, and those things kinda need to be said out loud now that didn't need to be said out loud so many years ago. And I and I and I… And, you know, in in a way, if if I, you know, sort of went by the by the rule of don't be a dick, and it turned out that was the wrong thing to do, that's not the one I wanna live in anyway. Right? You know what I mean? That… That's, you know, like, I want to live in the world that I want to live in in a way… The way you, you know, to use the word manifest manifest that world is you just live the world. If if all the citizens believe that they want a particular thing to happen in particular, and we all just did that, the world becomes that. Right? And the and and the… And that's that's empowerment. That's, like, sort of civil disobedience. That's where power comes from. And so the disappointing thing you see is so many people are hesitating, worrying, waiting for someone else to sort of bail them out, or this will happen, or this person will save me, or this, you know, blah blah blah, whatever it is. It starts with you. It starts with every single person to believe in the beginning that this is our moment. We need to think about what we wanna do and act in that direction. And then from there, you can what's going forward. Because right now, the systems that are giving us guidance, I can't really look at them and and trust that they're gonna give me good guidance. Unfortunately, that's where… I would prefer to be in a more… You know, what I grew up in was pretty great, but this is just where we are. That's just how I see it.
Speaker 2: Yeah. It's interesting. It's like, it's simultaneously such a skepticism about a rule set and just be like, these rule sets are just like ours to… Like, we negotiate them in real time. If a rule doesn't work, you go around it. At the same time, such a… Like, there's almost like a sacredness to, like, but don't be a dick. That is itself a rule, but it's, like, it's so profoundly important, and it should underpin all the others. And if you see one that isn't underpinned it, ignore it. Like…
Speaker 1: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 2: That's really cool. Yeah. Before we wrap up, I did have one more question kinda just about games and Xbox and stuff. Just because, I was really excited to talk to you this week. I know you as, you know, I first learned about you through hacking the Xbox. And just this week, we've had a really weird moment in hacking video games, I would say, broadly. This month, like, it's like AI assisted ports and decompilations and rips of of a bunch of classic games came out.
Speaker 1: Yeah.
Speaker 2: Yeah. It was all sort of open source undergroundy. And then we saw big institutional tech companies really kind of say it with their chest and put their foot forward on this and saying, no. We like this. Xbox has saying they have kind of a lab for decompiling and remixing and doing stuff with games. And I just found that so fascinating that I think that back of your book talks about, like, get hacking Xboxes because you won't be able to or before x… Microsoft does. And right now, we're living in a moment where Microsoft and Xbox are saying, we have a little lab dedicated to hacking apart games and remixing them and decompiling them. I was like, I was just curious what you make of this moment we're in right now.
Speaker 1: Yeah. I actually wasn't wasn't up to date on that last bit there where where… So so basically what's happening is is is Microsoft, like, saying all titles or just the old titles or
Speaker 2: Not all. It's not quite as cool as that of… It's not quite that. It's more that they're… They saw what was happening with people remixing games and, like, basically just being, like, we can just sick agents on this and and remake our own version, like, port it basically, saying they now have a lab dedicated to that. They haven't quite made it a product, but they've, like, they've expressed some interest in it. Okay. Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 1: That's interesting. No. I mean I mean, there's there's a… I I don't know the difference because I… That that…
Speaker 2: You know the details.
Speaker 1: I hadn't heard. I I heard… I've seen, like, you know, the import of whatever it is to this new system, like… Yep. And and and I've really enjoyed, seeing some of this come up with this last twist I hadn't seen. The the cynical part of me, you know, thinks that this this… You know, in a way, if you looked at maybe was already on the studio's minds, they're like, oh, they really love a sequel. And what's a SQL but a remix? Is this not the cheaper way to to crank out sequels? And we don't have to hire developers. And and we can just, like… If we just… And then and then, by the way, if inside the lab, these things got mixed together and this becomes a a sneak hit. Guess what we put in the… On the store, people just download for, like, a dollar a piece or whatever.
Speaker 2: That's interesting.
Speaker 1: Like like, that would be, like, my my first sort of, like, knee jerk. I don't wanna be… I hate being that cynical about it, but but but but that's sort of, like, the… My my my thought is to… Because it really depends upon, like, the details of which titles they're allowing, which ones they're not allowing. Yeah.
Speaker 4: No. It's
Speaker 1: You know, if they're really allowing people to touch their triple a stuff, the real pound jewels, then that's that's impressive. But if it's more, like, kind of older, depreciated stuff where they look at the cap table, how much cost to to keep those developers around, like, you know, just the whole BioWare thing. What if the whole BioWare library just now… You know, they're gone now. That's just an asset sitting there. How do we monetize them? Well, if I just throw in this lab here and somebody mix a BioWare thing, and all of a sudden we're
Speaker 2: getting interesting.
Speaker 1: And then it it just happens with a bunch of agents and some enthusiasts. Guess what? We didn't have to pay developers much deeper. Right? Like, I don't know. Like, that that details matter. Yeah.
Speaker 2: It's… Details really do matter. That's a super interesting point. People talk about how, YouTube is a television channel that has figured out how to not have to pay to produce any television. And I'm like, right. Right. You're a big company. You've bought a bunch of intellectual property that humans made, and you're like, how do we not have to pay to make more of this, but still get the value of the intellectual property?
Speaker 1: To find those people with the talent in doing it, you would have to do a job search. You have to pay for them. If you don't like them, you have to fire them. You just made a little lab that someone can jump into, and the agents are powerful, and they have us… Like, and and they have the creative spark. They had that one little insight that makes the game… Like, because the thing is at the end of the day, you're you're like… You know, to my mind, I'm just imagining this aging executive who's never played video games before. And he's in charge of, like, you know, a b… A bottom line. He's he's whatever, a brilliant corporate politician and tactician, whatever it is, but he has to now come up with a direction for this character line. Like…
Speaker 2: Like, no. It's not it's not what you… It's not what got you here. Yeah.
Speaker 1: Yeah. It's gonna it's gonna it's gonna come from some, you know, some kid who just has a cool idea and and a very meme y, catchy sort of thing, and then all of a sudden it catches on. And that's… How do you how do you how do you tap that? Right? Become sort of the challenge of these people who own these large pools of IP. And so I can say, yeah, YouTube is a is a way that you can make a TV channel where you don't pay for content. I mean, it's it's true.
Speaker 2: Buddy, I really appreciate you you taking the time to talk with me and what is now the middle of the night for you. Really appreciate it. You you you written in one of those letters to do with your book. It was without the right to tinker and explore, we risk becoming enslaved by technology.
Speaker 1: I think
Speaker 2: that's true. You're very excited about, like, open source and public good in technology. And I'm just curious to end on, like, on, like, a positive note. When it comes to the tinkering and exploring that's happening right now in the open source world, what are you excited about?
Speaker 1: Yeah. Yeah. I mean, like, so my my stick right now is, you know, open source hardware, open source silicon in particular. So, I'm super excited that, like, I recently got got a a very unique opportunity, to, sort of kind of participate in building a chip and a… Like, kind of an actual silicon chip. So cool. I think I have one of these here. It looks looks looks… Yeah. One of… It's that shiny little thing right here. Right? And it's it's in 22 nanometer silicon. So it's, like, a reasonably modern process. And I and I did this by hitchhiking on another company's… It normally costs millions of dollars to do. I don't have that. But the cool thing is that, like, most of the source for it is open. You can go online, and you can, like, read it and understand what happens inside the chip. And it's it's, like, I'm very excited that, like, people are are… Like, so a lot of people, like, for example, when they debug a program, the first thing it says, I need a debugger. I want GDB or whatever it is. Because the reason why they need that partially is because you can't get inside the processor's head. You kind of have to just go instruction by instruction. When you have the open source, you can actually simulate the processor and get inside the processor's head. You can see when the cache license are… When the cache lines are flushing. You can see when the branch predictor is hiccuping. You can see all this sort of stuff. You can really optimize your code. You can Cool. Debug horrific cross process memory space violations, because all of this is now simulatable at, like, a cycle accurate, almost, like, gate level simulation with with this sort of stuff available. Right? And so I'm really excited to sort of, get this, like, more people aware that this technology is sort of a thing now. And I wanna see what people kind of do, how it changes, how they develop, like, you know, people who do machine agents and stuff. They don't need to understand what the source code does for the chip, but they can put that in the context of their chip and say, like, now consider that we have a process that works like this, optimize for that. Right? And Cool. It just… You know, they'll just go ahead and start simulating for this sort of thing. So, like, that's that's kind of, like, you know, where I'm in a lot… And, of course, a a big part of my thing is about trust and transparency in technology. So, like, I have this existential worry that, like, I can't… Like, password managers are really weird. Like, the idea that you put something in, like, the cloud with your password and some… Like, something service that you can't even see inspect. Like, to me, that is just the craziest thing in my… In… You know, not… And so this is all part of this, like, long running sort of chaotic quest to build a thing I can fully trust that's transparent, that I can put my passwords in at the end of the day. Right? And… Because I wanna just keep some secrets to be able to bootstrap everything going on. And so and so I'm kind of excited that I can finally get that out there and share with people, doing the sort of stuff. The the company I made to do is called Bouchip, b a o c h I p. And there's a tie… I get terrible at web pages. So if you go to bouchip.com, you'd be like, wow. This web page looks like someone coded by hand. I literally wrote that by hand. Heck yeah. It will Heck yeah. Web page. But but but, yeah, I think it has the things you need for website. It's fine. Yeah. It has information. So, yeah, that's kind of what I'm excited about and working on right now.
Speaker 2: Incredibly cool. Again, thank you, Bonnie. I really appreciate you taking the time.
Speaker 1: Yeah. Thanks for having me.
Speaker 2: Thanks again to Andrew for coming on the show. It was a very fun conversation. And, again, a big thanks to NordLayer Intelligence for sponsoring Hacked. You can book your demo at nordlayer.com/intelligence/hackedpodcast. Go ahead and mention the code hacked podcast 10 for 10% off. Thank you again, Andrew. That was a lot of fun. Catch you on the next one.
Speaker 4: Black Friday is happening now at The Home Depot, and we've got just the tree for your style, space, and budget. Keep it merry and bright, then make it yours with ornaments and trimmings for every holiday style. With festive favorites starting at just $49, shop for the perfect tree at the number one Christmas tree retailer. Find the tree that feels just right with low prices guaranteed at the Home Depot. Exclusions apply. Visit homedepot.com/pricematch for details. The secret society of semi homemade? Listen up. Sam's Club has premade dishes for a Thanksgiving feast that's ready in two hours, all while tasting suspiciously homemade.
Speaker 1: Come join us. Sam's Club. Individual oven times may vary.
Speaker 5: Your sausage m'buffin with egg didn't change. Your receipt did. The sausage McMuffin with egg extra value meal includes a hash brown and a small coffee for just $5. Only at McDonald's for a limited time.
Speaker 3: Price and participation may vary. Promotion pricing may
Speaker 2: be
Speaker 1: lower than
Speaker 3: meal pricing.